It’s not what you wear, it’s how you wear it: a medieval fatwa on emulation

Joe Bradford

| 01/03/2012

Emulation of the non-Arabs in their dress
from the “M‘iyar al M‘urab” of Al Wansharisi (died 914), V.11/Pp.27-28

The pious jurist, the Mufti, Abu Abdullah Al Mawwaq was asked about the ‘Darnadin’ is it permissible to wear? It being a piece of roman clothing; emulation not being applicable when compared to the benefits wearing it has; it is a useful, economical piece of clothing which protects one from the cold.

He answered:
Not everything that the people of ignorance do is forbidden for us to perform, only that which the Shariah forbade and the principles of the religion indicate that it should be left alone is.The non-Arabs that we were forbidden from emulating are the Persian kings of that time because of their extravagance and the like. This prohibition is specific to those actions that they perform which are in direct contradiction to those things mandated by our religion. As for the recommended, obligatory, or permissible things in our religion that a [Muslim] does, then we are not to leave these things off merely because of their [i.e. non-Muslims] indulgence in similar actions [1].

The rationale here is that the Shariah does not forbid those things related to emulation while at the same time permitting them; The Messenger of Allah built the trench on the border of Medinah, emulating the Non-Arabs [in this action], astounding the Confederate forces, then later they came to know that this was done at the direction of Salman Al Farisi [2].

This [piece of clothing known as the] ‘Darnadin’  mentioned is economical, it is not extravagant, and is very useful, protecting one against the cold; It has been authentically narrated from the Messenger of Allah that he had worn a Roman coat with narrow sleeves [3].

Looking at this issue in another light, this have been stated explicitly by the esteemed scholars; the Messenger of Allah forbade the Arabs from emulating the Non-Arabs [4] yet it is not related from anyone that when the Non-Arab Delegations came to him that he forbade them from wearing their own clothing and ordered them to dress like the arabs…. (emphasis added).

——————————————

[1] See Al Taj wa _l Iklil of Al ‘Abdari, V.1/P.502

[1] See Al Fusul fi Sirat _l Rasul of Ibn Kathir, P.163

[2] Narrated by Al Tirmidhi (1768), Al Nisa_i (125), Ibn Majah (3563) and Ahmad (18265).

[3] Narrated by Ahmad (301) as the statement of Omar, who then narrates that the Messenger of Allah forbade the wearing of silk for men. The context of the narration shows that Omar understood this prohibition to be one forbidding emulation of the non-Arabs of that time in their extravagance. Similar to this is his prohibition of sitting on silk carpets (see Ibn Majah 3654) and tiger skins (see Ibn Majah 3656).

Share

3 thoughts on “It’s not what you wear, it’s how you wear it: a medieval fatwa on emulation”

  1. So, what is the take away that you are implying from this posting? Please add some additional comments.

  2. Abu Yusif,
    What do you understand from this fatwa? My point here was to accentuate a medieval edict that many people might not be aware of, and draw attention to several of the principles contained therein.
    What are some of the principles that we can derive from this fatwa?

Comments are closed.

Related Posts

Spanish Rice Paella - Photo by Young Shih on Unsplash

Cooking Rice, Not Engineering It: Al-Shatibi’s Guidance on relevance in Usul al-Fiqh Studies

May 17, 2023

Consider the process of teaching someone to cook rice. You wouldn’t initially throw them into a deep discussion about the variations among Fahrenheit, Celsius, and…
Photo by Abdulmeilk Aldawsari: https://www.pexels.com/photo/monochrome-photo-of-opened-quran-36704/

Is it Forbidden to Pay Riba? Or is it only forbidden to charge it?

September 8, 2022

Recently someone presented to me the opinion or the assumption that it’s not forbidden to pay interest, it’s only forbidden to take interest claiming that…

Personal Finance: What is your net worth?

August 24, 2022

So you’re wondering what your net worth is. Your net worth is essentially everything you own minus everything that you owe. So if you have…

NFTs: Non-Fungible Tokens – A Very Simple Explanation

November 19, 2021

NFTs give you something that can’t be copied. Not a picture itself (anyone can take a screenshot). Here we’re going to use art as an…

When is staking your crypto allowed?

November 16, 2021

There are three situations in the market currently where they use the word “staking” but mean something different each time. You need to learn what’s…

What makes a crypto coin Shariah Compliant?

November 16, 2021

For those of you concerned with the Shariah compliance of the coins you are buying, Asking yourself these 5 questions will help guide your coin…

Zakat on Assets – A Quick Review

April 12, 2021

Let’s talk Zakat on Assets: – 1st, assets you do not pay Zakat on. – 2nd, assets you do pay Zakat on. – 3rd, deductions and expenses that…

Is SAFE document Equity Conversion Shariah Compliant?

March 23, 2021

SAFE documents are not loans. They are warrants for future equity. The structure found in the SAFE agreement is permissible and offers a viable, interest-free…

Book Excerpt – The Greatest Gifts

June 10, 2020

The following is an excerpt from a collection of short essays I’ve been writing over the last few years, each one encapsulates an event in…