Radicalization in the Muslim Community – NYT: “Uncle Sam is No Imam”

Joe Bradford

| 02/21/2012

The New York Times recently published an Op-Ed from Samuel Rascoff, from the article:

From a national security point of view, challenging ideas that underpin radical Islam makes sense. Counterterrorism is ultimately about ideas; why shouldn’t officials try to marginalize the theological teachings cited by violent terrorists?

The problem is that when American officials intervene in Islamic teachings — interpreting them to believers in a national-security context and saying which are or are not acceptable — they create tensions, both legal and strategic.

The legal tensions are obvious, but the strategic tensions may be lost on many Americans. With a significant number of US Muslims coming from countries where government intervention hegemony advises dictates the confines of faith, US government programs will naturally cause mistrust, and may push some towards radicalism.

Out of fear of government reprisal, many Islamic centers around the nation seek to remedy radicalism in the different ways. At times they buy into the blame game, so there is an eradication of religious leadership from the community. “Imam-less” communities are a trend in several areas of the US, yet these areas still suffer from radicalized elements, as disaffected youth raised in the united states find the lack of leadership puzzling, especially when leadership decisions are being made by volunteers wholly unqualified to offer professional much less religious opinion. Where will these people go then?

On the other hand a neutered form of “spiritual” Islam is promoted in which practices are unsubstantiated textually, and Imams are merely “prayer leaders” and “spiritual guides” with no leadership influence beyond “praying for the congregation”. Community decisions that are at the heart of the ethics of Islam (from Eid, to Zakat, to the proper use of donated funds, to the treatment of women in the mosque) lack transparency, and cause further stagnation of positive community growth, while encouraging radical attitudes to rear their ugly heads.

When a layperson feels that his/her local mosque is misappropriating anything entrusted to it, a natural suspicion will develop in the community. Many who have lived under repressive regimes will notice a trend, as many such countries promote a faith embodied in prayer alone, with other religious acts (from zakat to fasting, to social work and humanitarian efforts) as hand-off. This will drive those people further away from the place they should be coming for guidance, and towards ill-informed arenas for gathering Islamic knowledge (Sheikh Google and Peer Wiki Saheb).

What then is the solution? Lay Muslims often will say authoritatively “There is no clergy in Islam” True, in the sense that we have no ecclesial hierarchy. There is however a concept of authority, in areas of faith, governance, and organizational representation. While it is obvious that there should be no unilateral leader in any community, a system of checks and balances needs to be created wherein qualified Imams are hired, empowered, and given the freedom to be the authorities of their realms. When qualified individuals are not nurtured, trained, and empowered to serve their communities, we ourselves are creating a leadership crisis. When the individuals that represent religious authority in the community are themselves seen as puppets, we cannot expect those that would lean towards radicalism to confide in them and reform their ideas. We certainly can’t expect them to stay away, as they will consistently try to mend the rift created from what they see is a compromised religious ideal.

From the article:

Countering radical religious ideology is on much more solid constitutional — and strategic — footing if the heavy lifting is done not by the government but by grass-roots organizations that are grounded in civil society or in religious communities. The government must not be heavily and directly involved.

This is a good start, but we as Muslims must analyze these issues internally. The solution, in my humble opinion, lies in not just creating institutions and initiatives that are grounded in faith, socially relevant, and legally viable, but in reevaluating what it means to have religious leadership; Who really is an Imam? Who speaks for Islam? What sort of faith do we have in our texts, and what sort of trust do we have in those entrusted to interpret it? If we cannot answer this latter question, and instead allow ourselves to interpret it, how are the personal interpretations of some laypeople (say non-radicals) more authoritative and valid than those of others (say radicals)?

When we are the only religious community in the US that actively marginalizes our religious leadership, and one of the only communities in which religiously uninformed opinion decides who or what religious leadership is, then it is no wonder that Uncle Sam would try to fill the void that we have created.

Share

9 thoughts on “Radicalization in the Muslim Community – NYT: “Uncle Sam is No Imam””

Comments are closed.

Related Posts

Spanish Rice Paella - Photo by Young Shih on Unsplash

Cooking Rice, Not Engineering It: Al-Shatibi’s Guidance on relevance in Usul al-Fiqh Studies

May 17, 2023

Consider the process of teaching someone to cook rice. You wouldn’t initially throw them into a deep discussion about the variations among Fahrenheit, Celsius, and…
Photo by Abdulmeilk Aldawsari: https://www.pexels.com/photo/monochrome-photo-of-opened-quran-36704/

Is it Forbidden to Pay Riba? Or is it only forbidden to charge it?

September 8, 2022

Recently someone presented to me the opinion or the assumption that it’s not forbidden to pay interest, it’s only forbidden to take interest claiming that…

Personal Finance: What is your net worth?

August 24, 2022

So you’re wondering what your net worth is. Your net worth is essentially everything you own minus everything that you owe. So if you have…

NFTs: Non-Fungible Tokens – A Very Simple Explanation

November 19, 2021

NFTs give you something that can’t be copied. Not a picture itself (anyone can take a screenshot). Here we’re going to use art as an…

When is staking your crypto allowed?

November 16, 2021

There are three situations in the market currently where they use the word “staking” but mean something different each time. You need to learn what’s…

What makes a crypto coin Shariah Compliant?

November 16, 2021

For those of you concerned with the Shariah compliance of the coins you are buying, Asking yourself these 5 questions will help guide your coin…

Zakat on Assets – A Quick Review

April 12, 2021

Let’s talk Zakat on Assets: – 1st, assets you do not pay Zakat on. – 2nd, assets you do pay Zakat on. – 3rd, deductions and expenses that…

Is SAFE document Equity Conversion Shariah Compliant?

March 23, 2021

SAFE documents are not loans. They are warrants for future equity. The structure found in the SAFE agreement is permissible and offers a viable, interest-free…

Book Excerpt – The Greatest Gifts

June 10, 2020

The following is an excerpt from a collection of short essays I’ve been writing over the last few years, each one encapsulates an event in…